The Sims 3: Supernatural Reviews

Supernatural received mixed reviews. Metacritc gave the Supernatural expansion a metascore of 74 out of 100. The review was based on 16 critic reviews. The average user score on Metacritic is 6.3 out of 10.

IGN
IGN gave the Supernatural expansion a scathing review, claiming that "Supernatural doesn't augment your Sims or make the neighborhood more interesting: it turns it into an unrecognizable mess..." The review repeatedly mentions how chaotic the expansion is, and also mentions an intitial release bug that corrupted save files.

IGN rated the expansion 4.5 out of 10.

Games Radar
Games Radar had a more favorable review for Supernatural than IGN. Games Radar even referred to Supernatural as "one of the strongest expansions for the core game yet." The review raved about all the new life states and new items.

Games Radar rated the expansion 4 out of 5 - Great.